You misunderstood my initial point. An insult is only affective if the person being insulted feels insulted. What the insulter means by something is generally not relevant to the feeling of the apparent insultee.

And I don't believe I did in fact suggest that a theist is uninterested in logic. If that's your interpretation, so be it, but it's not what I meant; I've since clarified what I did mean, but if you need a further explanation, ask, and I'll provide one.