I, Robot was stylish looking, but pretty terrible. It didn't really make much sense.

I actually thought that I, Robot was a fairly decent movie.... as long as you completely disassociated it in your mind from the Asimov story of the same name.

A familiarity with the original story probably helped with "getting" the movie, but if you approach the movie with the expectation that it's going to be a faithful adaptation of Asimov's story, you're gonna have a bad time.